One of the charges of contradiction brought by skeptics against the bible is the surface appearance of contradiction between matthews genealogical list 1. However, his birth narratives were different in the books of luke and matthew. Luke, on the other hand, gives the ancestry of jesus through mary from whom jesus was descended physically as to his humanity. Matthew and luke actually give two different genealogies. It tells of the origins, birth, ministry, death, resurrection, and ascension of jesus christ. Matthew s account traces the line of descent from abraham to jesus, while luke s account follows the ancestry from adam to jesus. Compare the gospel of matthew and the gospel of luke 123. Mark views jesus as a miracle worker while matthew views him as a teacher. What are the difference in the books of matthew mark luke.
A comparison between matthew and mark while both books of mark and matthew portray peter as one of the most important followers of jesus, mark seems to emphasize jesus spiritual career unlike the broad, more indepth pursuit of jesus life that matthew embellishes on. Matthew s genealogy starts at abraham and goes to david. Jan 02, 2020 matthew traces the line through davids son solomon matthew 1. Luke is the longest gospel that covers twentyfive percent of the entire new. Why are there two demonpossessed men in the gerasene tombs in matthew, but only one in mark and luke. Luke pictures jesus delivery of the beatitudes as an eye to eye. What are the differences between the gospel of mark and luke. Jesus birth narratives in matthew and luke biblebridge bible. In fact, between david and jesus, the only names the genealogies have in common are shealtiel and zerubbabel matthew 1. The matthew account mentions two demonpossessed men, while mark and luke only.
Matthews genealogy starts at abraham and goes to david. Despite the gospel of matthew being the first book in the new. Why do mathew and luke present a different order of satan. Between adam and abraham, luke demonstrates new hermeneutical skills. What many people dont know, however, is that theres a striking difference between the first three gospels matthew, mark, and luke, which are known together as the synoptic gospels and the gospel of john.
Q is reconstructed by taking everything matthew shares with luke but not mark, and it turns out to be a book of wise sayings. Oct 24, 2007 a comparison of the gospels of matthew and luke. Why do matthew and lukes genealogies contradict one another. The list may be through marys side, but because matthew omits some of the names, lukes genealogy could be josephs from another branch. Start studying similarities and differences between luke s and matthew s infancy narratives.
Start studying similarities and differences between lukes and matthews infancy narratives. And by far, john is the most accomplished, having more years to study than the previous authors. In this video, i explain why jesus family tree is different in the gospel of matthew and the gospel of luke. Compare and contrast the birth narratives in the gospel of matthew and that of the gospel of luke.
It is interesting, however, that while matthews statement is clear, lukes is strikingly specific. Matthew gives the genealogy of jesus through joseph, the legal, though not the physical father of jesus. Doing what jesus says in the sermon on the mount, randy harris and i make the case for these sayings of jesus being blessings more than attitudes. Why do matthew and luke have different nativity stories.
Unanswered questions what is the particular type of processor model and operating system on which a computer is. Matthew traces the line through davids son solomon matthew 1. There is a slight difference between the gospels of mark and matthew in the bible. Student of cca advanced biblical studies and ministry school. The two source hypothesis is an explanation for the synoptic problem, the pattern of similarities and the differences between the three gospels of matthew, mark and luke. What many people dont know, however, is that theres a striking difference between the first three gospels matthew, mark, and luke, which are known together as the synoptic gospels. A comparison between matthew and mark in the bible essay. Mormon matters 16425 there is a slight difference between the gospels of mark and matthew in the bible. Jun 14, 2017 i am not an expert but i will try to give a short answer. Continuing our walk through the book of acts, we can note the following similarities between what happened to jesus in the gospel of luke and what happens in the life of the church in acts.
It has more old testament quotations than the other three gospels. In the synoptic gospels matthew, mark, and luke, jesus visits jerusalem. The remaining two matthew and luke have very different accounts. Luke is the longest of the four gospels and the longest book in the new testament. Differences in the lords prayer not just another book. The writing of the gospels relationship between the. When we look at matthew s view of discipleship and, although it can be and has been overstated, there is nevertheless a perceivable difference between the relatively negative, or at least very ambivalent portrait of the disciples in mark, and a somewhat more positive picture of them in matthew.
These three have the same basic outline of an oneyear ministry for jesus who, after his baptism by john, begins preaching and healing in galilee, gathers disciples, and then by the following spring comes to judea and jerusalem for the confrontation with the religious authorities. There are two bases of similarities in the synoptic gospels but many differences. Both matthew and luke apparently had independent sources besides mark and q. One of the ways each book does this is by recounting jesus genealogy. Similarities and differences between lukes and matthews. But there are not just differences between the two, there are also discrepancies.
John and matthew both agree that jesus carried his cross out of jerusalem. They only partly correspond to matthew s, in that the. Highlighting the similarities and differences between jesus birth. Matthews account traces the line of descent from abraham to jesus, while lukes account follows the ancestry from adam to jesus. From the seventeen parables found in matthew and nineteen in luke, six are held in common. Matthew begins with a genealogy to show jesus heritage and then tells of his miraculous conception and birth without any reference to a journey to bethlehem. What are the difference in the books of matthew mark luke and john in the bible. One would also be able to see why these gospels should be considered the same.
Indeed, any adult reader of the gospels of matthew, mark, luke and john will notice many substantial overlaps as well as the differences among them. The four accounts of jesus life and ministry vary in their content. Some differences between the synoptic gospels and the. The tone, tenor and plot of lukes account of the jesus birth narrative is very. The gospels of matthew and luke will be surveyed in order to observe the similarities and differences in these texts. Andrea perch matthew luke announcement of the immaculate conception announcement of the immaculate conception joseph was planning on dismissing mary until an angel announced to. Comparing matthew and lukes birth narratives living on. On the other hand, luke s genealogy reveals the physical genealogy of jesus. I spent time comparing and contrasting them, along with christmas carols from the.
Matthew and luke both indicate that the primary recipients of the sermon are the disciples, including more than just the twelve matt 5. Matthew and luke are at clear odds in their infancy narratives in important. When the genealogies arrive at david, they split with davids sons. Andrea perch matthew luke ontario religious education. Differences in the gospels, a closer look the exchange a. Explaining the differences between john and the synoptic.
Both matthew and luke are believed to have incorporated most of marks gospel into their own, adding their own. Jan 17, 2008 the gospel of mark is believed to be the first one written and mark, who is believed to have been a follower of the apostle peter, wrote down peters remembrances of christ and his ministry. Matthew begins with a genealogy to show jesus heritage and then. These are my musing and notes surrounding the birth narratives as told in luke 12 and matthew 12. The birth narratives in both matthew and luke help answer the question, who is jesus and where did he come from. What are the difference in the books of matthew mark luke and. The gospel of luke is unique or different from other two synoptic gospels. Differences in the gospels, a closer look the exchange a blog. Mathews report on the sermon of the mound is different than lukes in that matthews report is practically three times as long as that of luke. Being longer, matthews account of the sermon on the mount contains more.
Why do mathew and luke present a different order of satans. In between, special matthew includes mostly parables, while special luke includes both parables and healings. Here are the differences between lukes and matthews narrative birth stories. Of course, the biggest difference between the accounts is in the fact that luke mentions that there are intermediaries between the centurion and jesus. The beatitudes of matthew and luke deo ac veritati. The list may be through marys side, but because matthew omits some of the names, luke s genealogy could be josephs from another branch. Apologetics press the genealogies of matthew and luke. Of the four gospels only matthew and luke give us narratives of jesus birth. According to dieter betz, a similarity between between the two sermons of matthew and luke is that these contain a guide for the conduct of the disciple on this earth.
Why are there different genealogies for jesus in matthew 1. Alan, the gospel of luke in the new interpreters bible nashville. Start studying differences between matthews and lukes beatitudes. Navigating the differences in the gospels faith and leadership. Five differences between matthew and lukes versions of the christmas story by. Matthew follows the line of davids son solomon, while luke follows the line of nathan, another son of david. The gospels of matthew, mark, and luke are referred to as the synoptic gospels because they include many of the same stories, often in a similar sequence and in similar or sometimes identical wording. The tone, tenor and plot of luke s account of the jesus birth narrative is very different from that in matthew s gospel. Their narrative stories about jesus birth are different. In the synoptic gospels matthew, mark, and luke, jesus visits jerusalem only once during. The difference between matthew and lukes account of the. Would jesus christ not be confused about his own birth. Start studying differences between matthew s and luke s beatitudes. Differences between the gospel of john and the synoptic.
Comparing the gospel of matthew and the gospel of luke. Within the beatitudes themselves, there are at least four notable differences. Brown suggests that if the order in the q document was the same as in luke, then matthew changed it to have the scene end on the mountain, matching the mountain. Oct 01, 2014 in this video, i explain why jesus family tree is different in the gospel of matthew and the gospel of luke. In luke the conversation takes place between jesus and jewish elders who speak on behalf of the. Differences in the gospels, a closer look the exchange. He was a legitimate claimant to the throne of israel. Synoptic is a greek word meaning having a common view. Differences between the gospel of john and the synoptic gospels and acts the gospel according to john is very different than the other three gospels aka synoptic gospels matthew, mark, and luke as well as the book of acts.
The three passages that describe the incident with the demoniacs in the country of the gerasenes, also called gadarenes, are matthew 8. Matthew, mark, and luke are often called the synoptic gospels. A comparison of the gospels of matthew and luke the student. Matthew was written by a former tax collector, one of the 12 apostles. How is the sermon on the mount different in matthew and luke. Why are jesus genealogies in matthew and luke different.
This is because matthew was focusing on the teachings of jesus whereas luke focused on the historical story of jesus. Both matthew 1 and luke 3 contain genealogies of jesus. Nov 01, 20 what john didnt record but matthew did include is that outside the city as they came out in matthew 27. It is interesting, however, that while matthew s statement is clear, luke s is strikingly specific.
It is set on grander scale, mary is more prominent, and joseph recedes into the background. Only this gospel has a sequel the acts in the new testament. Matthew also makes no reference to a stable, manger, shepherds or donkeys. Why is jesus genealogy different in matthew and luke. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Differences between the luke and matthew birth accounts. Mark strauss study from the bible and be encouraged to grow your faith.
Each demonstrates a greater knowledge of the mystery, and uses hermeneutic tools not used previously. Quite a few differences and discrepancy exist between the. Why are jesus genealogies in matthew and luke so different. Apr 12, 2010 jesus, while not josephs actual son according to heredity, became the legal heir when joseph married mary and thus adopted him. The birth narrative of matthew begins with a long genealogy of jesus, which basically shows how jesus is son of abraham who is the father of the nation of israel, and david the king of the jews. In the account of jesus healing the centurions servant, there appear to be differing accounts.
The difference between matthew and lukes account of the jesus. These two gospels have been chosen due to the similarities they share. Comparing the gospel of matthew and the gospel of luke meditation on gods word opens doors to more understanding, his wisdom and an earnest desire to know gods perfect will. A comparison of the gospels of matthew and luke the. Some of their content can be found in all four while other parts are unique to that particular gospel. Why are there two demonpossessed men in the gerasene. If you are the son of god, command these stones to become loaves of bread. Serious readers of the gospels notice various differences between them.
Quite a few differences and discrepancy exist between the two records. According to the chronology of the gospels detailed in important dates in the lives of jesus and mary, chapter 11, matthew wrote between 3 to 6 years after christs ascension, mark wrote between 15 and 16 years after the ascension, luke wrote between 25 to 27 years after the ascension, and john wrote between 49 and 62 years after the ascension. You are correct to discern the marked difference between john and the other three gospels, matthew, mark and luke. Then scholars have a dispute regarding the birth of jesus christ because of luke and matthew. Mark and matthew each used a different term to refer to jesus. Both matthew and luke provide genealogies of jesus that confirm he was a descendent of davidtherefore, a legitimate messiah. The first basis for similarities is that the gospels of matthew and luke were substantially based on marks gospel. In the gap between abraham and john, matthews new tool set can be observed. The gospel of mark is believed to be the first one written and mark, who is believed to have been a follower of the apostle peter, wrote down peters remembrances of christ and his ministry. The tone, tenor and plot of lukes account of the jesus birth narrative is very different from that in matthews gospel. It is my firm belief then, that we must learn to read it differently and think about it in different terms. Luke is the longest gospel that covers twentyfive percent of the entire new testament. This is a beautiful fulfillment of prophecy and actually testifies to the accuracy of the bible.
Both special matthew and special luke include distinct opening infancy narratives and postresurrection conclusions with luke continuing the story in his second book acts. Why are jesus genealogies in matthew and luke zondervan. Stein notes that there is a striking difference in the number of beatitudes in luke, who writes four compared to matthews eight more developed beatitudes. Rather than viewing this difference between matthew and luke as being something to disparage scriptures, i see it as god working to assure that the fullness of meaning and intent, of his original words, would be carried into all future translations by having this builtin comparative duplication. The classic nativity scene is actually an amalgamation of the different gospel accountsreuters. Some differences between the synoptic gospels and the gospel of john the synoptic gospelsmatthew, mark and lukeoffer such strikingly similar accounts of the life and teachings of jesus christ that, according to one author, they can be placed side by side and viewed horizontally harris 103. Sep 27, 2018 the birth narratives in both matthew and luke help answer the question, who is jesus and where did he come from.
1268 787 476 616 982 536 107 82 1470 442 1434 69 1434 1307 985 453 699 955 577 1016 667 29 1093 1409 1052 1371 1196 1233 711 1181 801